Buddha nature: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
(35 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''Buddha nature''' — when the [[Buddha]] became enlightened he realized that all beings without exception have the same nature and potential for [[enlightenment]], and this is known as buddha nature. | [[Image:Skycloudsun.jpg|thumb|350px|The sun covered by clouds, a common metaphor for buddha nature temporarily veiled by the [[obscurations]]]]'''Buddha nature''' (Tib. ཁམས་ / རིགས་, ''kham / rig'', [[Wyl.]] ''khams''/''rigs'') [lit. element/family or lineage] — when the [[Buddha]] became enlightened he realized that all beings without exception have the same nature and potential for [[enlightenment]], and this is known as buddha nature. | ||
[[Orgyen Tobgyal Rinpoche]] says: | [[Orgyen Tobgyal Rinpoche]] says: | ||
:It is because this ground or sugatagarbha or potential is common to all beings that they are capable of attaining enlightenment. If they did not have such a ground then they could never become buddhas. | :It is because this ground or ''sugatagarbha'' or potential is common to all beings that they are capable of attaining enlightenment. If they did not have such a ground then they could never become buddhas. | ||
:For example: a stone doesn’t have the ‘ground’ or potential to produce oil, and so no matter how much you might press it and grind it—even if you use modern tools and machinery—you will never extract any oil. A sesame seed, on the other hand, does have the potential to produce oil, and by pressing it in the right way, sesame oil can and will be produced. So it is because the potential exists as part of our basic nature that we can become buddhas. | :For example: a stone doesn’t have the ‘ground’ or potential to produce oil, and so no matter how much you might press it and grind it—even if you use modern tools and machinery—you will never extract any oil. A sesame seed, on the other hand, does have the potential to produce oil, and by pressing it in the right way, sesame oil can and will be produced. So it is because the potential exists as part of our basic nature that we can become buddhas. | ||
[[Sogyal Rinpoche]] writes: | [[Sogyal Rinpoche]] writes: | ||
:When we say [[Buddha]], we naturally think of the Indian prince Gautama Siddhartha who reached enlightenment... ''Buddha'', however, has a much deeper meaning. It means a person, any person, who has completely awakened from ignorance and opened to his or her vast potential of wisdom<ref>See etymology in [[Buddha]] article</ref>. A buddha is one who has brought a final end to suffering and frustration, and discovered a lasting and deathless happiness and peace. | :When we say [[Buddha]], we naturally think of the Indian prince Gautama Siddhartha who reached enlightenment... ''Buddha'', however, has a much deeper meaning. It means a person, any person, who has completely awakened from [[ignorance]] and opened to his or her vast potential of wisdom<ref>See etymology in [[Buddha]] article.</ref>. A buddha is one who has brought a final end to suffering and frustration, and discovered a lasting and deathless happiness and peace. | ||
:But for many of us in this skeptical age, this state may seem like a fantasy or a dream, or an achievement far beyond our reach. It is important to remember always that Buddha was a human being, like you or me. He never claimed divinity, he merely knew he had the buddha nature, the seed of enlightenment, and that everyone else did too. | :But for many of us in this skeptical age, this state may seem like a fantasy or a dream, or an achievement far beyond our reach. It is important to remember always that Buddha was a human being, like you or me. He never claimed divinity, he merely knew he had the buddha nature, the seed of enlightenment, and that everyone else did too. | ||
:The buddha nature is simply the birthright of every [[sentient beings|sentient being]], and I always say, “Our buddha nature is as good as any buddha’s buddha nature.” This is the good news that the Buddha brought us from his enlightenment in [[Bodhgaya]], and which many people find so inspiring. His message—''that enlightenment is within the reach of all''—holds out tremendous hope. Through practice, we too can all become awakened. If this were not true, countless individuals down to the present day would not have become enlightened.<ref>''[[The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying]]'', pages 48-49</ref> | :The buddha nature is simply the birthright of every [[sentient beings|sentient being]], and I always say, “Our buddha nature is as good as any buddha’s buddha nature.” This is the good news that the Buddha brought us from his enlightenment in [[Bodhgaya]], and which many people find so inspiring. His message—''that enlightenment is within the reach of all''—holds out tremendous hope. Through practice, we too can all become awakened. If this were not true, countless individuals down to the present day would not have become enlightened.<ref>''[[The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying]]'', pages 48-49.</ref> | ||
==How Do We Know That We Have Buddha Nature?== | ==How Do We Know That We Have Buddha Nature?== | ||
[[Ringu Tulku Rinpoche]] | [[Ringu Tulku Rinpoche]] writes<ref>Ringu Tulku, ''Path to Buddhahood'' (see references in 'Further Reading' section above). A similar oral teaching given by Ringu Tulku Rinpoche to Shedra East students is also available on the [[Ringu Tulku Rinpoche 2008 teaching MP3]] page.</ref>: | ||
: | :Although we are in [[samsara]], we can still see proof of the existence of buddha nature permeating all living beings. [One] way<ref>Ringu Tulku, in the same book, mentions two other ways to prove that all living beings have buddha nature—through scriptural authority and through describing precisely what buddha nature is and then determining if and how it manifests in beings.</ref> in which we can discern whether beings have buddha nature is ''rik'' ( Skt. ''gotra''; Tib. རིགས་, [[Wyl.]] ''rigs'') [see terms for buddha nature below], in other words the quality we perceive in one who possesses this buddha nature. [...] All beings have buddha nature because all beings have within themselves what we call the essence of the buddha, this ''ju'' (Skt. ''hetu''; Tib. རྒྱུ་, Wyl. ''rgyu''), this seed, which can blossom into a buddha and which constitutes our potential for enlightenment. | ||
: | :But what is a buddha? Briefly, a buddha is one who has developed his or her compassion (Tib. ''tsé'') and wisdom (Tib. ''khyen'') to the ultimate level, beyond all limits. Wisdom, in this context, refers not to an accumulation of knowledge but to the ability to see the true nature of things. what characterizes a buddha therefore is wisdom and compassion. | ||
: | :To determine whether buddha nature exists in all beings, we need to examine whether they possess the qualities of wisdom and compassion. Without wisdom and compassion, it is impossible to become a buddha, but if one possesses even an embryonic amount of these qualities, one can them develop them to their ultimate level and become buddha. The most concrete proof of the presence of this nature is that we possess, to varying degrees, these qualities of wisdom and compassion. | ||
: | :According to Buddhism, there is no being, human or otherwise, who doesn't possess some wisdom and some compassion. However bad, however evil, every being has a minimal amount of love, kindness, or compassion, at least for themselves or for one other being. | ||
[[Maitreya]] says: | |||
:{| class="wikitable" style="color:black;background-color:#f7f7e7;" cellspacing="5" border="0" text-align:left,top" | |||
|+ | |||
|valign="top"| | |||
{{:Quotations: Maitreya, Sublime Continuum, Why all beings have buddha nature}} | |||
|} | |||
==Terms for Buddha Nature== | ==Terms for Buddha Nature== | ||
The usual term for ‘buddha nature’ in the [[Mahayana]] teachings is '''tathagatagarbha''', but in the [[Vajrayana]] the term is '''sugatagarbha'''. | The usual term for ‘buddha nature’ in the [[Mahayana]] teachings is '''tathagatagarbha''', but in the [[Vajrayana]] the term is '''sugatagarbha'''. | ||
*Essence of the Bliss Gone (Skt. ''sugatagarbha''; Tib. ''deshek nyingpo''; [[Wyl.]] ''bde gshegs snying po'') | *Essence of the Bliss Gone (Skt. ''sugatagarbha''; Tib. ''deshek nyingpo''; Tib. [[བདེ་གཤེགས་སྙིང་པོ་]], [[Wyl.]] ''bde gshegs snying po'') or བདེ་བར་གཤེགས་པའི་སྙིང་པོ་, (''dewar shekpé nyingpo'') | ||
*Essence of the Thus Gone (Skt. ''tathāgatagarbha''; | *Essence of the Thus Gone (Skt. ''tathāgatagarbha''; དེ་བཞིན་གཤེགས་པའི་སྙིང་པོ་, ''deshyin shegpé nyingpo'', [[Wyl.]] ''de bzhin gshegs pa'i snying po'') | ||
*Class/Family/Lineage/Heritage/Gene/Potential (Skt. ''gotra''; Tib. ''rik'' | *Affinity/Class/Family/Lineage/Heritage/Gene/Potential (Skt. ''gotra''; Tib. [[རིགས་]], ''rik'', [[Wyl.]] ''rigs'') | ||
*Element (Skt. ''dhātu''; Tib. ''kham'' | *Element (Skt. ''dhātu''; Tib. [[ཁམས་]], ''kham'', [[Wyl.]] ''khams'') | ||
==The Two Kinds of Potential (Skt. ''gotra'')== | ==The Two Kinds of Potential (Skt. ''gotra'')== | ||
Line 36: | Line 44: | ||
In his ''[[Khenjuk]]'', [[Mipham Rinpoche]] writes: | In his ''[[Khenjuk]]'', [[Mipham Rinpoche]] writes: | ||
:The 'naturally present potential' (Wyl. ''rang bzhin gnas rigs'') is the essence of the [[tathagata]]s. In essence, it is naturally arising and uncompounded wisdom, the union of awareness and [[emptiness]], the [[dharmadhatu]] which has always been inseparable from the [[kaya]]s and [[five wisdoms|wisdoms]]. It is naturally pure, the nature of things, just as it is, pervading all phenomena, beyond any transition or change, like space. Although it is within this context that the ordinary [[five skandhas|aggregates]], elements and faculties of beings are born and die, this nature itself remains beyond birth and death. It is through the realization of this nature that the [[Three Jewels]] come into being. This immaculate 'element' (Wyl. ''khams'') is present in all beings without exception as the very nature of their minds, just like the example of a treasure beneath the earth and so on. Nevertheless, for those in whom this nature remains veiled by the four stains, and who have not activated their potential, despite its presence, it does not function in an apparent way [rather like a candle kept inside a jar]. And although they are naturally pure, because they are obscured by temporary veils, this nature is beyond most people's imagination. If the veils that obscure the potential are reduced, it serves to inspire us with a longing to leave [[samsara]] behind and attain [[nirvana]]. | :The 'naturally present potential' (Skt. ''prakṛtistha-gotra''; Wyl. ''rang bzhin gnas rigs'') is the essence of the [[tathagata]]s. In essence, it is naturally arising and uncompounded wisdom, the union of awareness and [[emptiness]], the [[dharmadhatu]] which has always been inseparable from the [[kaya]]s and [[five wisdoms|wisdoms]]. It is naturally pure, the nature of things, just as it is, pervading all phenomena, beyond any transition or change, like space. Although it is within this context that the ordinary [[five skandhas|aggregates]], elements and faculties of beings are born and die, this nature itself remains beyond birth and death. It is through the realization of this nature that the [[Three Jewels]] come into being. This immaculate 'element' (Wyl. ''khams'') is present in all beings without exception as the very nature of their minds, just like the example of a treasure beneath the earth and so on. Nevertheless, for those in whom this nature remains veiled by the four stains, and who have not activated their potential, despite its presence, it does not function in an apparent way [rather like a candle kept inside a jar]. And although they are naturally pure, because they are obscured by temporary veils, this nature is beyond most people's imagination. If the veils that obscure the potential are reduced, it serves to inspire us with a longing to leave [[samsara]] behind and attain [[nirvana]]. | ||
:The four veils that obscure our potential are (1) an antipathy to the [[Mahayana]] teachings, (2) the view of self, (3) fear for the sufferings of samsara, and (4) a lack of concern for beings' welfare. | :The four veils that obscure our potential are (1) an antipathy to the [[Mahayana]] teachings, (2) the view of self, (3) fear for the sufferings of samsara, and (4) a lack of concern for beings' welfare. | ||
Line 42: | Line 50: | ||
:The causes for purifying these veils are: (1) an interest in the Mahayana teachings, (2) a high degree of [[wisdom]], (3) meditative concentration (''samadhi''), and (4) love. | :The causes for purifying these veils are: (1) an interest in the Mahayana teachings, (2) a high degree of [[wisdom]], (3) meditative concentration (''samadhi''), and (4) love. | ||
:When we possess these four, through the force of awakening our potential, we come to possess the 'developing potential' (Wyl. ''rgyas 'gyur gyi rigs'') through which we can properly cultivate the virtues of the Mahayana. | :When we possess these four, through the force of awakening our potential, we come to possess the 'developing potential' (Skt. ''samudānīta-gotra''; Wyl. ''rgyas 'gyur gyi rigs'') through which we can properly cultivate the virtues of the Mahayana. | ||
==Texts on Buddha Nature== | |||
===Sutras=== | |||
*[[Ten sutras that teach the sugatagarbha]] | |||
==Treatises | ===Indian Treatises=== | ||
*[[Maitreya]], ''[[Uttaratantra Shastra]]'' | *[[Maitreya]], ''[[Uttaratantra Shastra]]'' | ||
*[[Rangjung Dorje]], ''Treatise on Buddha Nature'' (''snying po bstan pa'') | *[[Nagarjuna]], ''[[Praise to the Dharmadhatu]]'' | ||
===Tibetan Treatises=== | |||
*[[Rangjung Dorje]], ''Treatise on Buddha Nature'' (Wyl. ''snying po bstan pa'') | |||
*[[Mipham Rinpoche]], ''[[The Lion's Roar: A Commentary on Sugatagarbha]]'' | |||
==Teachings | ==Teachings Given to the [[About Rigpa|Rigpa]] Sangha== | ||
* [[Tsoknyi Rinpoche]], The Buddha Nature and the Introduction of the Right View of Meditation: Rigpa centre [[L'Orangeraie, Paris]], 29-30 May 1999 | |||
*[[Tsoknyi Rinpoche]], The Buddha Nature and the Introduction of the Right View of Meditation | * [[Khenpo Namdrol]] taught on [[Mipham Rinpoche|Mipham Rinpoche's]] ''[[Khenpo Namdrol 2008 Teachings on Buddha Nature|The Lion's Roar: A Commentary on Buddha Nature]]'' during Rigpa Shedra East, [[Pharping]], Nepal, December 2008. The teachings are available online as part of the [[Shedra MP3 Library]] and the MP3s can be downloaded [[Khenpo Namdrol 2008 Teachings on Buddha Nature|here]]. | ||
*[[Sogyal Rinpoche]], Torino, Italy, 19 September 2010 | |||
===Edited Teachings of Sogyal Rinpoche=== | |||
*''Buddha Nature'', Dzogchenlink September 2008, CDE260 (compilation of teachings from 2008) | |||
*''Buddha Nature, Parts One and Two'', Rigpalink August-September 2009, LCE726 (compilation of teachings from 2009) | |||
==Further Reading== | ==Further Reading== | ||
*Douglas S. Duckworth, ''Mipam on Buddha-Nature: The Ground of the Nyingma Tradition'', State University of New York Press, 2008. | *Douglas S. Duckworth, ''Mipam on Buddha-Nature: The Ground of the Nyingma Tradition'', State University of New York Press, 2008. | ||
*Andy Karr, ''Contemplating Reality'' (Shambala Publications | *[[Geshe Sonam Rinchen]], ''Buddha Nature'', Translated & Edited by Ruth Sonam, LTWA, 2003. | ||
*S.K. Hookham, ''Buddha Within: Tathagatagarbha Doctrine According to the Shentong Interpretation of the Ratnagotravibhaga '', State University of New York Press, 1992. | |||
*[[Jamgön Kongtrül]], ''The Light of Wisdom Volume 1'', Ch. 8 'The Meaning of the Ground' & Appendix 4, 'The Sugata Essence' (Hong Kong: Rangjung Yeshe, 1995) | |||
*[[Andy Karr]], ''Contemplating Reality'' (Boston: Shambala Publications, 2007), pages 168-173. | |||
*[[Ringu Tulku]], ''Path to Buddhahood'' (Boston: Shambhala, 2003), '1. The Cause: Buddha Nature', pages 7-13. | |||
*[[Tulku Urgyen Rinpoche]], ''As It Is, Vol. I'', Chapter 1 'The Basis: Buddha Nature', Rangjung Yeshe, 1999. | |||
==Notes== | ==Notes== | ||
<small><references/></small> | <small><references/></small> | ||
==External Links== | |||
*[https://buddhanature.tsadra.org/ Buddha-Nature, A Tsadra Foundation Initiative] | |||
*{{LH|topics/buddha-nature|Buddha Nature series on Lotsawa House}} | |||
[[Category:Key Terms]] | [[Category:Key Terms]] | ||
[[Category:Philosophical Tenets]] | [[Category:Philosophical Tenets]] | ||
[[Category:Buddha Nature]] | [[Category:Buddha Nature]] |
Latest revision as of 12:37, 18 December 2023
Buddha nature (Tib. ཁམས་ / རིགས་, kham / rig, Wyl. khams/rigs) [lit. element/family or lineage] — when the Buddha became enlightened he realized that all beings without exception have the same nature and potential for enlightenment, and this is known as buddha nature.
Orgyen Tobgyal Rinpoche says:
- It is because this ground or sugatagarbha or potential is common to all beings that they are capable of attaining enlightenment. If they did not have such a ground then they could never become buddhas.
- For example: a stone doesn’t have the ‘ground’ or potential to produce oil, and so no matter how much you might press it and grind it—even if you use modern tools and machinery—you will never extract any oil. A sesame seed, on the other hand, does have the potential to produce oil, and by pressing it in the right way, sesame oil can and will be produced. So it is because the potential exists as part of our basic nature that we can become buddhas.
Sogyal Rinpoche writes:
- When we say Buddha, we naturally think of the Indian prince Gautama Siddhartha who reached enlightenment... Buddha, however, has a much deeper meaning. It means a person, any person, who has completely awakened from ignorance and opened to his or her vast potential of wisdom[1]. A buddha is one who has brought a final end to suffering and frustration, and discovered a lasting and deathless happiness and peace.
- But for many of us in this skeptical age, this state may seem like a fantasy or a dream, or an achievement far beyond our reach. It is important to remember always that Buddha was a human being, like you or me. He never claimed divinity, he merely knew he had the buddha nature, the seed of enlightenment, and that everyone else did too.
- The buddha nature is simply the birthright of every sentient being, and I always say, “Our buddha nature is as good as any buddha’s buddha nature.” This is the good news that the Buddha brought us from his enlightenment in Bodhgaya, and which many people find so inspiring. His message—that enlightenment is within the reach of all—holds out tremendous hope. Through practice, we too can all become awakened. If this were not true, countless individuals down to the present day would not have become enlightened.[2]
How Do We Know That We Have Buddha Nature?
Ringu Tulku Rinpoche writes[3]:
- Although we are in samsara, we can still see proof of the existence of buddha nature permeating all living beings. [One] way[4] in which we can discern whether beings have buddha nature is rik ( Skt. gotra; Tib. རིགས་, Wyl. rigs) [see terms for buddha nature below], in other words the quality we perceive in one who possesses this buddha nature. [...] All beings have buddha nature because all beings have within themselves what we call the essence of the buddha, this ju (Skt. hetu; Tib. རྒྱུ་, Wyl. rgyu), this seed, which can blossom into a buddha and which constitutes our potential for enlightenment.
- But what is a buddha? Briefly, a buddha is one who has developed his or her compassion (Tib. tsé) and wisdom (Tib. khyen) to the ultimate level, beyond all limits. Wisdom, in this context, refers not to an accumulation of knowledge but to the ability to see the true nature of things. what characterizes a buddha therefore is wisdom and compassion.
- To determine whether buddha nature exists in all beings, we need to examine whether they possess the qualities of wisdom and compassion. Without wisdom and compassion, it is impossible to become a buddha, but if one possesses even an embryonic amount of these qualities, one can them develop them to their ultimate level and become buddha. The most concrete proof of the presence of this nature is that we possess, to varying degrees, these qualities of wisdom and compassion.
- According to Buddhism, there is no being, human or otherwise, who doesn't possess some wisdom and some compassion. However bad, however evil, every being has a minimal amount of love, kindness, or compassion, at least for themselves or for one other being.
Maitreya says:
- རྫོགས་སངས་སྐུ་ནི་འཕྲོ་ཕྱིར་དང༌། །
དེ་བཞིན་ཉིད་དབྱེར་མེད་ཕྱིར་དང༌། །
རྟག་ཏུ་སངས་རྒྱས་སྙིང་པོ་ཅན། །
རིགས་ཡོད་ཕྱིར་ན་ལུས་ཅན་ཀུན། །
Because the perfect buddhas’s kaya is all-pervading,
Because reality is undifferentiated,
And because they possess the potential,
Beings always have the buddha nature.
- Maitreya, Sublime Continuum, I, 27
Terms for Buddha Nature
The usual term for ‘buddha nature’ in the Mahayana teachings is tathagatagarbha, but in the Vajrayana the term is sugatagarbha.
- Essence of the Bliss Gone (Skt. sugatagarbha; Tib. deshek nyingpo; Tib. བདེ་གཤེགས་སྙིང་པོ་, Wyl. bde gshegs snying po) or བདེ་བར་གཤེགས་པའི་སྙིང་པོ་, (dewar shekpé nyingpo)
- Essence of the Thus Gone (Skt. tathāgatagarbha; དེ་བཞིན་གཤེགས་པའི་སྙིང་པོ་, deshyin shegpé nyingpo, Wyl. de bzhin gshegs pa'i snying po)
- Affinity/Class/Family/Lineage/Heritage/Gene/Potential (Skt. gotra; Tib. རིགས་, rik, Wyl. rigs)
- Element (Skt. dhātu; Tib. ཁམས་, kham, Wyl. khams)
The Two Kinds of Potential (Skt. gotra)
In his Khenjuk, Mipham Rinpoche writes:
- The 'naturally present potential' (Skt. prakṛtistha-gotra; Wyl. rang bzhin gnas rigs) is the essence of the tathagatas. In essence, it is naturally arising and uncompounded wisdom, the union of awareness and emptiness, the dharmadhatu which has always been inseparable from the kayas and wisdoms. It is naturally pure, the nature of things, just as it is, pervading all phenomena, beyond any transition or change, like space. Although it is within this context that the ordinary aggregates, elements and faculties of beings are born and die, this nature itself remains beyond birth and death. It is through the realization of this nature that the Three Jewels come into being. This immaculate 'element' (Wyl. khams) is present in all beings without exception as the very nature of their minds, just like the example of a treasure beneath the earth and so on. Nevertheless, for those in whom this nature remains veiled by the four stains, and who have not activated their potential, despite its presence, it does not function in an apparent way [rather like a candle kept inside a jar]. And although they are naturally pure, because they are obscured by temporary veils, this nature is beyond most people's imagination. If the veils that obscure the potential are reduced, it serves to inspire us with a longing to leave samsara behind and attain nirvana.
- The four veils that obscure our potential are (1) an antipathy to the Mahayana teachings, (2) the view of self, (3) fear for the sufferings of samsara, and (4) a lack of concern for beings' welfare.
- The causes for purifying these veils are: (1) an interest in the Mahayana teachings, (2) a high degree of wisdom, (3) meditative concentration (samadhi), and (4) love.
- When we possess these four, through the force of awakening our potential, we come to possess the 'developing potential' (Skt. samudānīta-gotra; Wyl. rgyas 'gyur gyi rigs) through which we can properly cultivate the virtues of the Mahayana.
Texts on Buddha Nature
Sutras
Indian Treatises
Tibetan Treatises
- Rangjung Dorje, Treatise on Buddha Nature (Wyl. snying po bstan pa)
- Mipham Rinpoche, The Lion's Roar: A Commentary on Sugatagarbha
Teachings Given to the Rigpa Sangha
- Tsoknyi Rinpoche, The Buddha Nature and the Introduction of the Right View of Meditation: Rigpa centre L'Orangeraie, Paris, 29-30 May 1999
- Khenpo Namdrol taught on Mipham Rinpoche's The Lion's Roar: A Commentary on Buddha Nature during Rigpa Shedra East, Pharping, Nepal, December 2008. The teachings are available online as part of the Shedra MP3 Library and the MP3s can be downloaded here.
- Sogyal Rinpoche, Torino, Italy, 19 September 2010
Edited Teachings of Sogyal Rinpoche
- Buddha Nature, Dzogchenlink September 2008, CDE260 (compilation of teachings from 2008)
- Buddha Nature, Parts One and Two, Rigpalink August-September 2009, LCE726 (compilation of teachings from 2009)
Further Reading
- Douglas S. Duckworth, Mipam on Buddha-Nature: The Ground of the Nyingma Tradition, State University of New York Press, 2008.
- Geshe Sonam Rinchen, Buddha Nature, Translated & Edited by Ruth Sonam, LTWA, 2003.
- S.K. Hookham, Buddha Within: Tathagatagarbha Doctrine According to the Shentong Interpretation of the Ratnagotravibhaga , State University of New York Press, 1992.
- Jamgön Kongtrül, The Light of Wisdom Volume 1, Ch. 8 'The Meaning of the Ground' & Appendix 4, 'The Sugata Essence' (Hong Kong: Rangjung Yeshe, 1995)
- Andy Karr, Contemplating Reality (Boston: Shambala Publications, 2007), pages 168-173.
- Ringu Tulku, Path to Buddhahood (Boston: Shambhala, 2003), '1. The Cause: Buddha Nature', pages 7-13.
- Tulku Urgyen Rinpoche, As It Is, Vol. I, Chapter 1 'The Basis: Buddha Nature', Rangjung Yeshe, 1999.
Notes
- ↑ See etymology in Buddha article.
- ↑ The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying, pages 48-49.
- ↑ Ringu Tulku, Path to Buddhahood (see references in 'Further Reading' section above). A similar oral teaching given by Ringu Tulku Rinpoche to Shedra East students is also available on the Ringu Tulku Rinpoche 2008 teaching MP3 page.
- ↑ Ringu Tulku, in the same book, mentions two other ways to prove that all living beings have buddha nature—through scriptural authority and through describing precisely what buddha nature is and then determining if and how it manifests in beings.